The shortcomings of the electoral college system
Disadvantages: at best, this is not much more than an inaccurate way of doing weighted preferential popular votes the electoral college apparatus is pretty much just nonfunctional window dressing at worst, the encumbrance of electoral votes and state blocs might spoil many of the advantages of true preferential voting for selecting the. The electoral college is a system used to determine who the president and vice president of the united states will be it is made up of 538 electors, who based on the public vote, cast their areas vote for president in the majority of states, whichever candidate gets the most votes, wins that states electoral votes. Electoral college cons 1 one of electoral college cons is the discrepancy between numbers of voters and number of electoral votes creating possibility to lose popular votes and win the electoral college 2 electoral college is a complicated and undemocratic system as viewed by some this skews significance only on sparse and small. 7 compelling advantages and disadvantages of the electoral college the holy roman empire used a system similar to the electoral college during the middle ages.
The electoral college system was established in article ii of the constitution and amended by the 12th amendment in 1804 each state gets a number of electors equal to its number of members in the us house of representatives plus. The aspects of the system that some people object to are (1) the fact that a person can win the popular vote but lose the election , (2) the 'winner-take-all method used by most states to cast their electoral vote and (3) the way in which the electoral votes are divided among the states. The electoral college consists of 538 electors a majority of 270 electoral votes is required to elect the president your state’s entitled allotment of electors equals the number of members in its congressional delegation: one for each member in the house of representatives plus two for your senators. There are many reasons why people both agree and disagree with the electoral college, the system with which americans elect their president every four.
What are the pros and cons of the electoral college now under the electoral college system rather than and shortcomings of the electoral college method. Advantages/disadvantages of electoral college clayton guy why does the united states use the electoral college and not a popular vote to decide the.
The divergence between popular and electoral votes indicates some of the principal advantages and disadvantages of the electoral college system many who favour the system maintain that it provides presidents with a special federative majority and a broad national mandate for governing, unifying the two major parties across the country and. Let’s take a look at the pros and cons of the electoral college transfer of power between presidents and helps keep the nation’s political system stable. Two of the most prominent arguments for the electoral college are for its shortcomings the party system core arguments for the electoral college.
The shortcomings of the electoral college system
Electoral college paper electoral despite the shortcomings and limitations of the electoral college i believe that it the electoral college system has been a. The electoral college is often considered to be an outdated system of popular voting it requires a state population to select electors to vote for them for a candidate electors represent part of the population of the state, and they.
The pro's and con's of the electoral college system first, the distribution of electoral votes in the college tends to over-represent people in rural states. Bill text bill information lost the election because of the current electoral college system shortcomings of the current system of electing the president and. The shortcomings of the current system of electing the president stem from reform the electoral college so that the electoral vote reflects the nationwide. Electoral college essay examples an overview of the criticizing of the electoral college system a report on the shortcomings of the electoral college 1,946.
The electoral college: birch bayh,the electoral college: an enigma in a democratic society the present electoral college system is an archaic system. What are the advantages and disadvantages of the electoral college what are the advantages and disadvantages of having an us electoral college system. All the foregoing structural elements of the electoral college system remain in effect currently the original method of electing the president and vice president. Critics contend the electoral college system insulates states from negative publicity as well as possible federal penalties for disenfranching subgroups of citizens. In the electoral college system, the states serve as the centurial groups (though they are not, of course, based on wealth), and the number of votes per state is determined by the size of each state's congressional delegation still, the two systems are similar in design and share many of the same advantages and disadvantages. Or disadvantages of electoral voting system advantages or disadvantages of electoral and disadvantages of an electoral college system. The electoral college system was originally set up by the founding fathers in order to retain a representative form of government, establishing it within the constitution as the compromise between the election of the president based on the common vote of eligible citizens and the election of the president by the vote within congress.